- Tuesday, 9
February 2010
- Philadelphia
-
- Strip
club workers held for trial in patron's death
Four employees
of a Southwest Philadelphia strip club were held for trial
this afternoon in connection with the fatal beating of a
patron on Oct. 16 of last year.
Two other
employees of the Oasis Club, 6800 Essington Ave. were
cleared of all charges by Municipal Court Judge Karen Y.
Simmons.
James Koons, 31,
of Media, Delaware County, died from blunt-force trauma
which fractured his skull in the front and back, testified
Assistant Medical Examiner Dr. Sam Gulino.
Koons and a
longtime friend, George Foreacre, 35, of Secane, Delaware
County, got into an altercation with the club's bouncers
inside the establishment and were escorted out, according to
testimony from Foreacre and police and surveillance video
that was played during the 4 1/2 hour hearing.
The
confrontation continued in the parking lot, where Koons
sustained injuries from being struck, knocked down to the
ground or both, according to Gulino.
Though video
from the parking lot does not show who struck Koons,
prosecutors maintained that the fatal blow was thrown by
John Pettit, 48, of Pennsauken, N.J., who was described in
court as a club manager.
Pettit was held
on charges of third-degree murder, conspiracy, aggravated
assault, recklessly endangering another person, hindering
apprehension and related offenses.
Pettit, who had
been charged with general murder, has been in jail for more
than three months because of the prosecution's contention
that he threw the fatal blow. After ruling that he should be
tried for murder, however, the judge set bail at $150,000.
The other five
defendants already were free on bail.
Club owner
Robert Laflar, 43, was held for third-degree murder and
conspiracy. Bouncer Timothy Carpenter was held for
aggravated assault and recklessly endangering another
person, but charges of third-degree murder and conspiracy
were dropped.
Bouncer Edwin
Padua was held for third-degree murder, conspiracy,
aggravated assault and recklessly endangering another
person.
Bouncer Brendan
Davis, 32, who had been charged with third-degree murder,
was cleared of all charges. Club employee Staci Shoenberger,
33, who had been charged with hindering apprehension and
filing a false police report, also was cleared of all
charges.